Chuck Taylor All Star Rubber - Thunder
The green rubber ones are on my short list. I think they might get me thru a decent part of my winter riding.
I really wanted something waterproof for the coming el nino, as well as my annual week-in-the-snow at Christmas... I opted for "Thunder" because I figured it would be neutral enough to wear with whatever - but if they made the ultra-high top rubber chucks in a big enough size, I'd have gotten them in superhero yellow.
Also, they actually feel really good. Almost luxurious.
@crazyunclejoe The stitches don't leak?
@ardgedee I live in LA - it will probably be a while before I can verify the seal (but they aren't supposed to.)